Thoughts on the military and military activities of a diverse nature. Free-ranging and eclectic.

Tuesday, April 08, 2008

Flying Tank IV. [Conclusion]

This is coolbert:

In his book, "Inside the Red Army", Suvorov devotes an entire chapter to the subject of the "Flying Tank".

NOT, however, the Antonov A-40. Rather, Suvorov has in mind the Soviet Mi-24 "Hind" helicopter.




In the perspective of the Soviet general officer, according to Suvorov, there is almost no difference between a tank and a helicopter [attack version that is].

From the chapter, "Flying Tank":

"the Soviet generals believe that to all intents and purposes the helicopter is a tank. In fact they find it difficult to distinguish between the two."

A helicopter is related to the tank in that it can:

* "seize territory" [and hold].

* "high speeds and unrestricted cross-country performance".

* "approximately the same firepower[ helicopter has] as a tank".

* "can operate in open ground" [both tank and helicopter].

* "see[s] the enemy in front of them".

With regard to firepower and the ability to "seize territory", the Mi-24 helicopter is uniquely qualified. Very potent task-tailored weapons array can be employed AND CAN CARRY A SQUAD OF EIGHT INFANTRY AS WELL. BOTH AN ATTACK AND TRANSPORT HELICOPTER AT THE SAME TIME!!

The Mi-24 [in various versions] can be equipped with:

* Quad 12.7 mm machine guns.

* Anti-tank guided missiles [ATGM].

* Rockets.

* Cannon.

* Bombs.

Acquires and engages targets using:

* Forward looking infra-red [FLIR].

* Radar with moving target indicator [MTI].

* Low light television [LLTV].

The Mi-24 was also unique in that it possessed considerable ARMOR!

"Armored cockpits and titanium rotor head able to withstand 20-mm cannon hits."

The role of the Mi-24 is now somewhat passe'? The most recent versions of Russian attack helicopters [Ka-50 and Mi-28], while being able provide devastating firepower support, no longer have the capability to carry an eight man infantry squad! Territory can now be seized, but NOT held!?

Tank and helicopter almost one and the same? In the minds of the Soviet generals - - at the time - - yes!

coolbert.

Labels:

Flying Tank III.

This is coolbert:

When considering the hypothesis of "M-Day", as initially proposed by the Soviet General Grigorenko and expounded upon at length by the defector Suvorov, a flying tank, such as the Antonov A-40, or a similar species of tank thereof, and A TANK THAT COULD SHED IT'S TRACKS AND MOVE WITH GREAT SPEED VIA ROAD WHEELS ALONE would both have been absolutely essential.

"M-Day", the Red Army moving west in July of 1941 to "liberate" Nazi Germany and all of Europe in the process, required units and weapons whose mission is fundamentally OFFENSIVE IN NATURE!! Specifically, paratroop units to operate BEHIND ENEMY LINES and tanks designed for use in nations that possess GOOD road networks.

Paratrooper units can be thought of AS ONLY OFFENSIVE FORCES [name an instance of paratroopers have been dropped behind FRIENDLY LINES!!?? A flying tank deployed in support of paratroopers COULD HAVE ONLY BEEN DESIGNED WITH OFFENSIVE ACTION IN MIND!!

Same with the Soviet BT series of tanks. The BT tank was not a tank that possessed both good OFFENSIVE and DEFENSIVE capability. NOT a tank with versatility!

"The tanks [BT series] that were being produced . . had the name Mark BT, initials for the Russian words “high-speed [bistro] tank.” The Mark BTs had a speed of one mile per minute [100 kilometers or 60 miles per hour] and a radius of action without refueling of 440 miles. These tanks were also the first ever to have a diesel engine and they carried a weapons system that was very powerful at the time. Having said so many good things about these tanks, let us note one disadvantage: it was impossible to use them on Soviet territory."

[the tanks [BT series] did not have good cross-country mobility. It was not "impossible" to use them on Soviet territory, but they were not effective.]

"The tanks substituted [for] heavy armor speed and the ability to produce enormous quantities of them . . . They were only useful as an invasive tank [used for offensive purposes on territory other than Soviet territory] . . . They had a pair of detachable caterpillar tracks that let them travel anywhere, but slowly. To go fast, they must be on a good road and discard the tracks to continue traveling on wheels."

[track treads could be shed at will and the tank could proceed on road wheels. Quantity over quality. Enormous numbers exerting pressure en masse' on FOREIGN TERRITORY was the way to go with the BT series of tank!]

As to the hypothesis ["M-Day"] of Suvorov, here is what the British officer General Sir John Hackett has to say concerning the Soviet defector: [from the foreword to the book, "Inside the Soviet Army"]

"There is no doubt at all of the author's [Suvorov] right to claim unquestioned authority on matters which he, as a junior officer, could be expected to know about at firsthand and in great detail. Nevertheless, not everyone would agree with everything he has to say . . . I am sometimes bound to wonder whether he is always interpreting the evidence correctly . . . He tells the reader how he, being what he is - - that is to say, a product of the Soviet Army and the society in serves - - judges the military machine created in the Soviet Union under Marxism-Leninism, and how responded to it . . . Where he may seem to some readers to get it wrong, both in his conclusion about his own army and his opinions on military matters in the Western world, he is almost certainly representing views very widely held in his own service"

Right! Suvorov is seeing "the evidence" in the light of his training and experience as a Soviet military officer. Seeing "things" as a Soviet would see them. NOT as a western military "expert" would see the same thing! Absolute certainty is not so important here as is PERSPECTIVE!!

coolbert.

Labels:

Sunday, April 06, 2008

Flying Tank II.

This is coolbert:

Here is another version of the flying tank that was proposed during World War Two [WW2]. A flying wing type of glider [Baynes Bat], of British design, that actually flew in prototype version.



Did not ever come to fruition. The tank needed to meet specifications was not available. You had a wing without a tank rather than a tank without a wing!!

As without other proposed flying tanks, glider wings strapped to a tank, the glider/tank towed aloft to landing zone, released, flown to ground by a pilot, wings then discarded, the tank moving directly to combat.

[those eccentric British put the horse before the cart, or is it the other way around!?]

"The Baynes Bat was a famous experimental glider of the Second World War, designed by L.E. Baynes. It was used to test the tailless design that he had suggested as a means to convert tanks into temporary gliders so they could be flown into battle."

"In 1941 the British Sailplane Designer L.E.Baynes made a proposal that armoured fighting vehicles, such as the 8 1/2 ton tank, could be provided with detachable glider wings to enable them to be flown to battlefields behind tugs."

"a swept wing with vertical stabilizers on the wing-tips"

[the flying wing has become only "fly-able" with the advent of modern computers correcting constantly and supplementing the handling by a human pilot. Those vertical stabilizers have ONLY become common and popular on modern commercial aircraft as of recently [the last decade or so?]]

A flying wing glider designed to accommodate and fly into the landing zone a tank of no more than eight tons. This was evidently the British Tetrach tank.



Again, the idea was to have a light-weight [relatively speaking] tank land on the battlefield BEHIND ENEMY LINES in support of lightly armed paratroopers. Provide fire support besides what the parachutists could carry on their backs.

"The Tank, Light Mk VII, Tetrarch I was a British light tank produced during the Second World War, initially for the reconnaissance role but later for use by airborne forces."

The Tetrach was flown into combat, but INSIDE OF A GLIDER, NOT AS AN AUTONOMOUS FLYING VEHICLE!

"Airborne Armoured Reconnaissance Regiment, 6th Airborne Division- landed by Hamilcar glider as part of Operation Overlord on June 6, 1944 on the River Orne"

No mention is made of whether the pilot of the Bat WOULD ALSO BE A CREW MEMBER OF THE TANK! I would have to think that training a man to be both tank crew member and pilot would be too difficult, time consuming, and a waste of resources?!

The Bat was tested in 1/3 scale as a prototype and found to be suitable for operations. Had good handling characteristics, according to the test pilot, Kronfeld.

With a caveat:

"Robert Kronfeld finishes with his conclusions:"

"'In spite of its unorthodox design the aircraft handles similarly to other light gliders with very light and responsive controls and is safe to be flown by service pilots in all normal attitudes of flight'. So it is strange that when Captain Eric Brown, who was an extremely experienced test pilot flew it, he found such poor harmony of controls."

The name of Captain ERic Brown has been mentioned in a previous blog entry. The most highly respected British test pilot. Test flew a German Me-163 and Me-262 AFTER the war.

coolbert.

Labels:

Flying Tank I.



This is coolbert:

Place this one in the oddities and curiosities category. The flying tank. An idea that was worth of consideration?

A tank that would be flown into battle in support of airborne forces. Paratroopers landing FAR BEHIND enemy lines have always been susceptible to counter-attack. Parachutists can only go into battle equipped with what they can jump with and carry on their back. A flying tank would provide fire support and protection for the friendlies on the ground!

[think of Arnhem where the British paratroopers were subject to continual counter-attack by German tank units. The German parachutists jumped at Crete carrying only a pistol and dagger. Terrible losses incurred just trying to recover equipment dropped separately.]

We need to clear here! We are NOT talking about placing a conventional tank INSIDE of a glider or a transport aircraft. WE ARE TALKING ABOUT STRAPPING WINGS TO A TANK, TOWING THE "APPARATUS" TO A LANDING ZONE, RELEASING, ALLOWING THE "FLYING TANK" TO BE FLOWN TO THE GROUND BY A PILOT INSIDE OF THE TANK!! Once on the ground, the "beast" sheds the wings and goes into battle as an ordinary armored vehicle!

Developments of the flying tank prior to World War Two [WW2] included:

1. Soviet Antonov A-40.

"The Antonov A-40 Krylya Tanka ("tank wings") was a Soviet attempt to allow a tank to glide into a battlefield after being towed aloft by an airplane, to support airborne forces or partisans."




[and also for sowing mass panic in rear areas where you have administrative and logistic type soldier in abundance. Folks NOT figuring they will ever "smell smoke"! NOT prepared to handle the attack by tanks for which they do not have organic capability to fight. OR ARE EVEN EXPECTING TO ENCOUNTER!! Tank fright and mass flight from the battle scene is the result!!]

2. American "The Christie Flying Tank Project"



"How formidable a weapon the flying tank will be in actual warfare can be understood from the drawings. Tanks can land almost directly on protected enemy territory, shed their wings, and plunge into action with their 75 millimeter guns blazing."

"Flying Tanks that Shed Their Wings (Jul, 1932)"

"Imagine those two formidable weapons of modern warfare, the airplane and the armored tank, combined into one terrible machine of destruction! Fantastic as the idea sounds, it is fast taking physical shape as a reality for Uncle Sam’s army. The whole amazing story is presented to you in this important article."



[an article, mind you, written in 1932!!]

"IS WAR, already made terrible to contemplate by the invention of too-efficient methods of destruction, on the verge of being banished forever by an amazing new weapon so horrible in its possibilities that nations of the world will not dare to risk its fury?"

[war never became too horrible to contemplate, even after the advent of atomic weapons. This is a popular idea that has been around for some time? Some terrible weapon will be developed and the nations of the world will just up and say, "this is too much for us, now peace is the only way for us!!" Never seems to materialize!]

"This is the idea conjured up by J. Walter Christie"

"John Walter Christie (May 6, 1865 - January 11, 1944) was an American engineer and inventor. He is best known for developing the Christie suspension system used in a number of World War II-era tank designs, most notably the Soviet BT and T-34 series"

The flying tank of Christie would have differed in one significant area from that of the Soviet version. WAS NOT MERELY A GLIDER THAT REQUIRED TOWING TO THE TARGET LANDING ZONE AREA. Had an INTEGRAL ENGINE AND COULD FLY AS WOULD ANY CONVENTIONAL AIRCRAFT!!

Christie incorporated some interesting features into his design BESIDES the ability to fly. Could shed the tank treads and operate solely on the road wheels when used for fast movement on a conventional highway!

J. Walter Christie. One of the most significant weapons engineers and developers of all time? Prior to the Christie tank suspension system, tanks were very ponderous vehicles, slow and subject to constant breakdown [the original tank as fielded by the British in the First World War carried a mechanic as a crew member, the mechanic being needed to attend to constant breakdowns]. Tanks with the Christie suspension system became infinitely better at cross-country mobility with speed.

The Soviet trade and espionage organization, Amtorg, through subterfuge, was able to purchase, and evading trade restrictions, ship to the Soviet Union two Christie suspension equipped tanks, these tanks being reverse engineered for study. The Christie concepts for tanks were adopted whole-heartedly by Soviet designers, EVEN, IT WOULD SEEM, THE IDEA FOR A FLYING TANK!!!

coolbert.

Labels:

Wednesday, December 05, 2007

Armor - - Winter War.

This is coolbert:

Soviet tanks - - Winter War - - 1940.

Here are the armored cars and tanks that the Finnish anti-tank infantry units [men-a-foot] faced AND defeated with more or less their bare hands.

A melange' of Soviet tanks. Light tanks, medium tanks, heavy tanks, fast tanks, tanks to accompany infantry, tanks to fight other tanks [the Finns did not have tanks], amphibious tanks. An impressive array.

FAI, BA-3, BA-6, BA-10. Armored cars.



T-37, T-38.



T-26.



BT-2, BT-7.



T-28.



KV [Klementi Voroshilov]. Encountered only in very limited numbers. Used by Soviets in an experimental role.



T-34. Encountered only in very limited numbers. Used by Soviets in an experimental role.



Sisu means "guts" [actually much more than that]!! The Finns did possess sisu!!

coolbert.

Labels:

Men-a-foot II - - Finland [Conclusion]

This is coolbert:

Sisu - - "Finnish term that could be roughly translated into English as strength of will, determination, perseverance, and acting rationally in the face of adversity . . . . Usually sisu means the will and decisiveness to get things done against impossible odds, or to succeed when given the chinaman's chance."

Just as in the Spanish Civil War the infantrymen of Franco had to deal with massed tank attack with little more than their bare hands, the Finns in their Winter War of 1940 with the Soviet Union faced the same dilemma.

The figures are just staggering. The Red Army was able to deploy 5,000 tanks of varying types against the small Finnish Army. A Finnish Army that had NO tanks of it's own. And possessed only a small number of anti-tank guns.

Having made the cold-blooded decision to fight regardless of the odds, the Finns had to devise, and quickly, some sort of tactics to counter this overwhelming Soviet armor advantage.

Tactics that revolved around the anti-tank "hunter-killer" teams. Infantry, operating in small teams, to attack Soviet tanks with the most primitive of weaponry. Weaponry to include:

* Anti-tank mines. Mines not of the power or designed to DESTROY a tank. Mines normally disabling a tank by blowing off a track, but rarely more.

* Molotov cocktails. Gasoline bombs to be thrown at Soviet tanks from close range.




"a 1/2 liter liquor bottle with a screw cap was ideal for making this type of a weapon. As the flammable liquid, petrol, spirit, a mixture of petrol and kerosene or a mixture of waste spirit and kerosene, could be used . . . 1-2 cubic centimeters of tar to be added, to create smoke."

* Satchel charges. Ad hoc expedient blocks of explosive that could defeat armor at weak points when hurled ATOP a tank.



"the weaponry of these ad hoc AT-units' [called 'Short range" AT-defense' units by the Finns] consisted mainly of Molotov Cocktails, satchel charges, mines, hand grenades and 'blinding devices'('sokaisuvälineillä' in Finnish)."

All these forms of anti-tank "weaponry" useful ONLY when used at CLOSE RANGE.

"it was obvious that we [the Finns] would have to get awfully close to an enemy tank before we could throw one with any chance of success.”

To attack massed formations of tanks at such close range, again, calls for troops of the most resolute type, trained, equipped, and fighting AS A TEAM.

The Finnish infantry organized into anti-tank teams were resolute and determined. And did have some pluses going for them too! These being:

* Soviet tanks were commonly employed without any supporting infantry.

"It should also be noted, that in the early phases of the war . . . it was considerably easier for the Finnish AT-teams to destroy Soviet tanks, as the tanks usually attacked without supporting infantry."

* Soviet tanks of the era were equipped with gasoline fueled engines. Were prone to "brewing up" if attacked by a molotov cocktail.

"Before the war, the Molotov Cocktail was seen more as a weapon that would blind or suppress the target tank, making it easier to destroy it by other Molotov Cocktails or by satchel charges . . . The hot engine (the Soviet engines at that time were gasoline engines) of the tank caught fire quite easily, making this weapon quite effective against the tanks of early WW 2."

[T-34 and KV [Klementi Voroshilov] tanks had diesel engines and were not susceptible to attack by molotov cocktail flame weaponry!!??]

The most basic and rudimentary tactics sufficed when confronting Soviet tank formations.

"The tactic was simple; when the leading tank . . . hit an AT-mine . . . the two man team attacked the leading tank. While . . . one [Finnish trooper] 'blinded' the tank with blinding devices or a Molotov Cocktail, the other [Finnish troop] finished it off with a satchel charge. The explosion was the sign for the other teams [to begin their attack]"

The Finnish anti-tank teams were successful. They HAD sisu.

"Getting close to the tanks proved to be much easier than expected. Like their Spanish counterparts three years earlier, these Soviet tankers surged ahead of the infantry platoons designated to be their escorts . . . Finnish tank-destroyer teams often managed to get within touching distance of their targets, and were able to throw their missiles straight into the steel grilles covering their engine compartments, often with dramatic results."

"Not only did the Molotov cocktails work as advertised, but the enemy’s clumsy tactics made it relatively safe to approach an armored probe, deliver an accurate salvo of bombs, then retire into the cover of the nearby trees, all without being fired upon accurately in return."

HOWEVER, MAKE NO MISTAKE ABOUT IT. THIS WAS VERY DANGEROUS DUTY. CASUALTIES AMONG THE FINNISH ANTI-TANK TEAMS RAN ABOUT 70 %!!??

"The task of the close defense AT-teams was risky at best. The task of getting close to an enemy tank was hard and required courage and patience. You had to throw the satchel charge accurately and with just enough force to land it on top of a tank, to ensure a kill. You could also run to the tank and place it on the rear deck, but this was even more riskier. In some cases the soldier died from the blast of his own satchel charge . . ."

Sisu - - "strength of will, determination, perseverance, . . . adversity . . . . will and decisiveness . . . impossible odds"

Finnish anti-tanks were able to destroy 2,000 Soviet tanks during the Winter War. Amazing. The Finns WERE the best soldiers [John Keegan] of WW2??!! Probably so!

coolbert.

Labels:

Saturday, December 01, 2007

Men-a-foot I. [Spain]

This is coolbert:

Those of you that have seen the movie "Alexander" will remember the scene at the Battle of Gaugemela where the order is given:

"prepare to repel chariots!!"

The Macedonian infantry DO HAVE a battle drill worked out to deal with the "tanks" of the time. Even in ANCIENT time, soldiers [as opposed to warriors], were able to defeat "machines" that posed an awesome threat.

Several previous blog entries of mine have dealt with the problems faced by infantry [men-a-foot] when confronted by enemy tanks. Soldiers who in MODERN times, had to confront "machines".

Until the advent of the shaped-charge weapon of the panzerfaust variety, the infantry had only limited means to defend against tanks. Quite often, on the battlefield, "tank fright" would occur. Infantry fleeing in disorder when opposed by onrushing enemy tanks.

[Matt Ridgeway was heard to comment that American troops, while on maneuvers in Tennessee prior to deployment overseas during World War Two [WW2], when confronted by friendly [U.S.] tanks, threw away their weapons and fled the notional battlefield!!]

Read here how the Spanish Nationalist troop of Franco were able to repel attack by Soviet tanks during the Spanish Civil War.

"But historians generally agree that the first formal deployment of the Molotov cocktail by an organized army occurred during the Spanish Civil War in September, 1936."

"Francisco Franco’s Fascist army was slowly tightening a noose around Madrid . . . large formations of T-26 and T-28 tanks [Soviet tanks] the Loyalists were massing just east and north of Toledo."

"Franco’s most exposed infantry units were bolstered by the arrival of truck-loads of “bottle-bombs,” accompanied by crudely mimeographed user manuals and cursory instruction by a hastily organized training cadre."

"the Loyalist tankers . . . their armored wedges frequently advanced far beyond contact with the infantry assigned to protect them from close-range assault. The tactical situation was close-to-ideal for the use of hand-thrown petrol bombs. Once Franco’s soldiers the T-28s bursting into flames, they quickly regained the initiative and began to go “tank-hunting” with a vengeance . . . This was the first, and the last, time during Spanish conflict that Molotov cocktails were used in prolific numbers."

THANKS TO THE USE OF WHAT BECAME KNOWN AS THE MOLOTOV COCKTAIL, THE FASCIST INFANTRY FORCES OF FRANCO, NOT EQUIPPED WITH ANTI-TANK GUNS, WERE ABLE TO REPEL AND DEFEAT MASSED TANK ATTACKS OF THE LOYALIST FORCES!! MEN-A-FOOT, LIGHTLY ARMED, ROUTING TANK UNITS, THE INFANTRY HAVING LITTLE MORE TO WORK WITH THAN THEIR BARE HANDS!!

coolbert.

Labels: