Thoughts on the military and military activities of a diverse nature. Free-ranging and eclectic.

Thursday, November 22, 2007

Road to Hell III. [Conclusion]

This is coolbert:

Here is yet another example of how military units, road-bound and without an ability to maneuver, can be defeated by more adept and resourceful opposition.

The Finnish Motti.

"Motti is Finnish military slang for an encircled enemy unit, or the tactic of encircling it."

The Finns, in the Winter War of 1940, had repeated success in defeating road bound Soviet military columns. Soviet troops, lavishly equipped but whose movement was confined, found themselves at the mercy of determined, mobile, well-led Finnish ski troops.

Ponderous Soviet mechanized and armored columns, totally road bound, NO room for maneuver, found themselves beset by Finnish units just much more prepared, able, and proficient for the type of warfare fought in the heavily forested terrain of Finland.

[John Keegan rates the Finns as the best soldiers of World War Two [WW2]. The Finns too were provided with very good intelligence thanks to the cryptanalytic work of the Swede Arne Beurling.]

Trevor Dupuy would have said the Finns excelled over the Soviets because:

* [Finnish] leaders were more flexible, aggressive, and dynamic.

* [Finnish] doctrine, and its execution were better.

* More adaptable [the Finns.

* [AND, performed team tasks better.]

Soviet commanders in all likelihood were just largely inexperienced, inept, bound by inappropriate doctrine, pig-headed and under orders from a higher command [Stalin] totally out of touch with reality.

Extracts from the wiki say it best:

"This tactic of envelopment was used extensively by the Finnish forces in the Winter War . . . A motti is a double envelopment manoeuvre, using the ability of light troops to travel over rough ground to encircle an enemy restricted to open terrain or roads. Heavily outnumbered but mobile forces could easily immobilize an enemy many times more numerous."

[first, the head and tail of the road-bound Soviet column was simultaneously attacked, forward and backward movement becoming impossible.]

"The idea is to cut the enemy columns or units into smaller groups and then encircle them with light and mobile forces - such as ski-troops during winter. This turned out to be especially effective against some of the mechanized units of the Soviet Army, as they were effectively restricted to the roads. The Finnish troops on the other hand could move quickly through the forests and strike weak points. The smaller pockets of enemies could then be dealt with individually by concentrating forces against them."

[Right!! Those Soviet units confined to the roads had to guard against attack from all directions. Could NOT use their manpower or firepower advantage in a concerted manner either for defense or offense. The Finns could concentrate their forces, choosing the time and place for attack.]

"If the encircled enemy unit was too strong, or if attacking it would have entailed an unacceptably high cost, e.g. because of a lack of heavy equipment, the motti was usually left to 'cook' until it ran out of food, fuel, supplies and ammunition and was weakened enough to be eliminated. Some of the larger mottis held out until the end of the war, because they were resupplied by air."

"The largest motti battles in the Winter War occurred at the Battle of Suomussalmi. Three Finnish regiments enveloped and destroyed two Soviet divisions (already in retreat) as well as a tank brigade trapped on a road."



[the Finns in this instance had to be outnumbered at least MORE than two to one, with the firepower advantage overwhelmingly in favor of the Soviets. That did not deter the Finns even in the slightest manner!!]

At Suomussalmi, the opponents had at their disposal:

* Finns - - Three regiments and separate battalions (11,000 men.

* Soviets - - Two divisions, one tank brigade (45,000-50,000 men).

Finland - - si, Soviet - - no!

coolbert.

Labels: ,

Sunday, November 11, 2007

The Road to Hell II.


This is coolbert:

Braddock's approach to Ft. Duquesne [Pittsburgh] is another example of how a "road" can become a death trap for a military unit. A combination of negative factors all coming together at once to spell disaster.

This is of course the Braddock Expedition [French and Indian War]. Conventional European military commander, attempting to use conventional European tactics in the American wilderness. NOT using tactics appropriate for the terrain or the enemy.

"The Braddock expedition (also called "Braddock's campaign") was a failed British attempt to capture the French Fort Duquesne in the summer of 1755 during the French and Indian War. The expedition takes its name from General Edward Braddock, who led the British forces and died in the effort."

Even when warned, Braddock was not flexible and responsive to the conditions he faced! What worked well for a career officer like Braddock in Europe DID NOT WORK in the Allegheny Mountains of North America!

"Benjamin Franklin's autobiography includes an account of helping General Braddock garner supplies and carriages for the general's troops. He also describes a conversation with Braddock in which he explicitly warned the General that his plan to march troops to the fort through a narrow valley would be dangerous because of the possibility of an ambush."

"Braddock's Road - - Setting out from Fort Cumberland in Maryland . . . the expedition faced an enormous logistical challenge: moving a large body of men with equipment, provisions, and (most importantly for the task ahead) heavy cannon, across the densely wooded Allegheny Mountains and into western Pennsylvania, a journey of about 110 miles."

Move 110 miles to the west, BUT, where there was NO road at all. Those cannon, felt to be decisive, NEEDED a road, as would be present in the European environment. NO ROAD existed in the Allegheny Mountains that would accommodate the Braddock Expedition. A ROAD THAT HAD TO BE BUILT BY A PIONEER [QUASI-MILITARY ENGINEER UNIT] UNIT AS THE EXPEDITION MOVED FORWARD!!

"The expedition progressed slowly, in some cases moving as few as two miles a day, creating Braddock's Road—an important vestige of the march—as they went."

A march culminating in the Battle of the Monongahela.

What occurred was an absolute rout of the British forces and colonial militia. Road bound, attempting to use European-style tactics in unfriendly and hostile terrain, proved to be futile in the extreme.

"After an initial defense, Gage's [Gage - - colonial militia commander] advance group fell back. In the narrow confines of the road, they collided with the main body of Braddock's force, which had advanced rapidly when the shots were heard. The entire column dissolved in disorder as the Canadian militiamen and Indians enveloped them and continued to snipe at the British from the woods and ravines on the sides of the road."

NO ROOM to maneuver, CONFINED to the road and beset from all sides simultaneously, this must have been just absolute chaos!

These two items from the wiki entry catch my attention instantly:

* "Also, of the 50 or so women that accompanied the British column as maids and cooks, only 4 survived."

The wagon train, the baggage and "impedimenta", had fifty or so women present! ONLY made things worse. I bet the French and their American Indian allies had a field day with them.

* "the French commander Liénard de Beaujeu, who dressed himself in full war regalia complete with war paint, convinced them to follow his lead."

Here is an excellent example of a commander who rallies his men, inspires them, and leads them into combat IN A MANNER APPROPRIATE!! Lienard also perished in the combat??!!

An inflexible, stubborn commander [Braddock], using tactics not commensurate, his command road-bound, faced by an enemy that knew the terrain and how fight in same, was a recipe for British disaster from the start!

coolbert.

Labels:

The Road to Hell I.

This is coolbert:

Roads, as I have blogged about in previous entries, can be a tremendous BOON to the military. Allow supplies to flow where before NONE could!

Roads too, can also be a BANE to a military force.

Military units, devoted to movement by road, commanded by inexperienced or inept commanders, using inflexible or inappropriate tactics, can find themselves in precarious circumstances where OBLITERATION may be a consequence.

[a situation that can be made EVEN MORE precarious when confronted by an enemy who is more adept, flexible, responsive, using tactics suited for the situation.]

Perhaps from current history Mang Yang Pass is the archetype in this regard. Distinguished French troops, road-bound, almost totally annihilated by Viet Minh forces [First Indo-China War].

From ancient history, we have the destruction of three Roman Legions under the command of the consul Varus at the Battle of the Teutoburger Wald. Generally accepted to a major point in world history. NO further expansion of Roman power into Germania was EVER possible after this Roman debacle.

Excessive dependency upon roads combined with inclement weather [several days of continuous downpour!] placed the Roman legionnaires at great disadvantage. Inability to move forward or backward, no open terrain within which to maneuver, placed the Romans in great peril. Circumstances taken advantage of by the barbarians [Germanii]!

From the television series "I Claudius":

[a surviving Centurion reporting to Augustus Caesar what occurred on the battlefield.]

* "The wagons became mired in the mud and could not forward or backward."

* "The bow strings became wet, the archers being unable to fire their arrows."

* "The ox-hide shields were so sodden with water they could not be lifted."

* "The barbarians first attacked in small groups, then in ever increasing numbers."

* "Those Romans taken prisoner were placed in wicker baskets and burned ALIVE!!"

And from the history of Cassius Dio:

"They [Romans] had with them many waggons and many beasts of burden as in time of peace; moreover, not a few women and children and a large retinue of servants were following them"

[this impedimenta [Roman term] disallowed any possibility of inspired defense or maneuver. The Romans would have hesitated before abandoing the wagons and baggage train and civilians present!!]

"again a heavy downpour and violent wind assailed them [Romans] . . . they [Romans] could not handle their bows or their javelins with any success, nor, for that matter, their shields, which were thoroughly soaked."

FORTY YEARS AFTER THE ROMAN DISASTER, SURVIVORS BEING HELD AS SLAVES BY THE GERMANII WERE STILL BEING FOUND. ROMAN STANDARDS CAPTURED DURING THE BATTLE WERE RECOVERED, DECADES AFTER BEING LOST IN SOME INSTANCE!

coolbert.

Labels:

Saturday, November 10, 2007

Roads VI. [Conclusion]


This is coolbert:


"For hours, infinity to right, infinity to left, infinity behind us, infinity before us...the motor roaring in our ears…The boys on the convoy are over-whelmed by the vastness of their country. The nearing tropical north goes through them, impregnates, frightens, exalts, inspires them."


Stuart Overland Highway.

Australian route connecting Alice Springs with Darwin.

"Before WW2, the ‘road’ south from Darwin was an unsealed track that became a quagmire in the wet and a dust bowl in the dry. With the escalation of the Japanese threat to Northern Australia and surrounding sea lanes the authorities realised a road linking Darwin with the south had to be constructed to supply the top end in the event of a prolonged attack by the Japanese"

Guaranteed the Australian military a secure overland supply route to the beleaguered Northern Territories during WW2. 1000-mile road pushed through and completed in record time.

"The construction of the Alice Springs-Darwin Road constituted an engineering feat of considerable magnitude and of great military importance. As sections of the 1000 mile all-weather road was completed, convoys moved supplies between Alice Springs and Darwin."

A paved route unheard of in that part of the world! [Australians refer to a blacktopped, surfaced road as “sealed”] Was made deliberately wide to allow for the passage of military convoys. As with most of these World War Two [WW2] era roads, WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN CONSTRUCTED OTHER THAN DURING A WARTIME EMERGENCY!

The Overland highway was vital to the Australian war effort. Japanese bombing raids against the northern areas of Australia were more extensive than what I had realized.

If you are able to find a copy of the movie, “The Overlanders”, please rent and view. A semi-documentary filmed in 1946. Australian stock men [ranchers], moving their cattle south, away from the danger posed by a Japanese invasion of the Northern Territories. 1 million cattle were moved south in the traditional manner, a cattle drive as you would have seen in the American West, circa 1870.

"drovers droving a large herd of cattle 1600 miles overland from the Northern Territory outback of Australia to pastures north of Brisbane, Queensland during World War II."

[during the movement south, the Overland Highway is encountered by one group of stock men. Paved with “bitumen” is the remark heard!!]

coolbert.

Labels:

Friday, November 09, 2007

Roads V.

This is coolbert:

Alcan [Alaska-Canada] Highway.

Connecting the “lower” forty-eight contiguous states with Alaska. The latter at the time being a territory, NOT a state, but still considered to be of crucial importance to the war effort in the Pacific.

PRIOR TO THE BUILDING OF THE ALCAN HIGHWAY, THERE WAS NO LAND ROUTE FROM THE “LOWER” FORTY-EIGHT STATES TO ALASKA. Normal to- and-fro traffic would be by the sea route “inland passage”. A ROUTE THAT HAD BECOME PERILOUS AFTER THE DEBACLE AT PEARL HARBOR!!??

As with the Ledo Road, had been surveyed and proposed prior to World War Two [WW2]. Again, deemed unfeasible at the time. Given the exigencies of wartime, from the time the proposal to build the road was made until President Roosevelt gave his final approval was ONLY FIVE DAYS!!!

"n. pl. ex·i·gen·cies

The state or quality of requiring much effort or immediate action.
A pressing or urgent situation.
Urgent requirements; pressing needs."

[that five day approval would NEVER occur today under any circumstances.]

A road built in record-breaking time. Eighteen months from start to finish. As with the Ledo Road, built under trying circumstances. Bitter months-long sub-zero temperatures, permafrost, total lack of facilities of any nature, etc.

A road still used to this day [extensively??]. Reputed to be the BEST gravel road in the world. Incremental and sporadic improvements have been made over the decades. Traveling the Alcan Highway is still [?] considered to be an adventure.

coolbert.

Labels:

Thursday, November 08, 2007

Roads IV.

This is coolbert:

Road of Life.

WW2 road - - built on the frozen surface of Russian Lake Ladoga during the winters of 1941-1942 and 1942-1943. Allowed for resupply of the military and civilians of the besieged city of Leningrad. The 900-day siege of Leningrad is the type of “thing” that epics are made of. Mass starvation, cannibalism, eating wallpaper paste, etc., 1 MILLION persons dying during the siege!!

A “road” of course available ONLY during the winter months, when the surface of Lake Ladoga was frozen in a manner adequate to accommodate traffic. Traffic first consisting of horse drawn sleighs, then trucks, then A RAILROAD!! [as winter progressed and temperatures fell, the increasing thickness of the ice allowed for heavier loads to move.] Traffic at all times under attack by German aircraft and long-range artillery [just as was the case at Verdun!!].

"While the road was protected by anti-aircraft artillery on the ice and fighter planes in the air, truck convoys were constantly attacked by German artillery and airplanes"

It should be realized that when you have an instance [Leningrad] where resupply for military and civilian both is needed, priority WILL ALWAYS BE GIVEN TO THE MILITARY. THEIR NEEDS COME FIRST!!

coolbert.

Labels:

Wednesday, November 07, 2007

Roads III.

This is coolbert:

Ledo Road.

World War Two [WW2] road connecting British India with China. To supply the Chinese Nationalist forces with war-making munitions. A road built under the most impossible conditions imaginable. Mountainous terrain, jungle covered, monsoon rain a goodly part of the year, built under sporadic attack by Japanese forces. Had been surveyed prior to WW2 but deemed unfeasible! Amazing feats of civil engineering were required before the Ledo Road was complete, many setbacks being encountered along the way. ONLY completed JUST PRIOR to the end of WW2. Was a “white elephant” at the time of opening!

Winston Churchill called the project 'an immense, laborious task, unlikely to be finished until the need for it has passed'."




Look at that photo!! A section of the Ledo. Switchbacks all the way. Mountainous terrain. NOT AS A ROMAN WOULD HAVE BUILT A ROAD!!

Today the Ledo Road exists almost totally in name-only! A modern parallel route renders the military road useless! Read a recent National Geographic article on the Ledo Road!

coolbert.

Labels:

Tuesday, November 06, 2007

Roads II.


This is coolbert:

C’est Magnifique??


La Voie Sacree. The Sacred Road.

During the nine-month long siege of Verdun [World War One - - 1916], the French main supply route [MSR] consisted of a single gravel road with parallel narrow-gauge railway. Resupply for an army of HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF FRENCH TROOPS depended upon this one link remaining open and in repair.

OPEN AND IN REPAIR - - AND AT ALL COSTS!!

Each week during the nine-month siege passed along the Sacred Road:

* 90,000 troops [marching not on the road, but along side the road!!]

* 50,000 tons of ammunition in 12,000 trucks.

The most extraordinary effort was made to keep the Sacred Road open. ALL THE WHILE UNDER BOMBARDMENT BY GERMAN AIRCRAFT AND LONG-RANGE ARTILLERY!!

"The French were ultimately successful in defending and maintaining the road - adding some 700,000 tons of additional crushed stone by the end of the battle"

Maintenance and guarding of the Sacred Road primarily the responsibility of French Territorial "(a reserve force)" and Colonial troops. In the latter case, black Africans totally out of place in the cold and mud of Verdun. But doing yeoman work, valiantly, at great cost to themselves!!

coolbert.

Labels: